Short answer: You need a HERS rater — called an ECC-Rater under the 2025 code — when your Title 24 report lists measures that require field verification. Check the verification summary on your CF1R: if it lists items such as duct leakage, refrigerant charge or Quality Insulation Installation, an independent rater has to test them before final inspection. New homes, ADUs and many HVAC changeouts commonly need one; cosmetic work and like-for-like repairs usually do not. Your CF1R and your building department make the final call.
Need a Title 24 report for your permit?
ADU from $199 · Single-family from $245 · Multifamily from $345 per building. Permit-ready PDF in 2–3 business days, CHEERS-registered where required, two revisions included.
How to Tell From Your CF1R
The CF1R (Certificate of Compliance) settles the question. Every measure that needs field verification is listed on it, in a summary of HERS or ECC verification features near the compliance results. The exact heading can change between code cycles, but the content is the same: a list of what the rater has to test, or a statement that no verification is required.
- Items are listed: you need a rater. Typical entries are duct leakage, refrigerant charge, airflow, fan efficacy, Quality Insulation Installation (QII) and whole-house ventilation.
- Nothing is listed: field verification is not part of your energy compliance, although the building inspector still checks the work.
- No CF1R yet: the project type gives a good first idea (see the table below), and the report confirms it.
To see what the verification summary looks like on a real form, open our CF1R sample report, or read what a CF1R report contains.
When Is HERS Testing Required?
Verification follows the measures your project uses to comply, so two similar projects can end up with different lists. As a guide:
| Project | Rater needed? | Items often verified |
|---|---|---|
| New single-family home | Commonly yes | QII, duct leakage, refrigerant charge on heat pumps, airflow, fan efficacy, ventilation |
| New ADU | Commonly yes | Similar to a new home, depending on the HVAC system and compliance path |
| HVAC changeout (new heat pump or air conditioner) | Commonly yes | Duct leakage, refrigerant charge, airflow |
| Home addition | Sometimes | Depends on whether ducts or equipment are added or extended, and on the insulation path |
| Window replacement only | Often not | Check the CF1R |
| Cosmetic remodel, or like-for-like repair with no duct work | Usually not | Often no Title 24 report at all |
Under the 2025 code, refrigerant charge verification applies to heat pumps in every climate zone on the prescriptive path for new homes, so heat pump projects are among the most likely to need a rater. Your building department decides what applies to your permit. For changeouts, the HVAC replacement Title 24 page covers the rules in more detail.
Who Hires the Rater?
The rater must be independent of the contractor who installed the work; that separation is the point of third-party verification. In practice, the installing contractor usually schedules the rater, though owners and builders can hire one directly. A typical HVAC changeout runs like this:
- The contractor registers the project and pulls the permit.
- The contractor installs the equipment, completes the CF2R and schedules the rater.
- The rater tests the listed items, completes the verification forms (CF3R) and the Project Status Report.
- The building inspector checks the registered forms at final inspection.
Title24Comply prepares the Title 24 report and registers the CF1R where the project requires it. We do not perform HERS field testing, so the rater is a separate hire. Our guide to CF1R vs CF2R vs CF3R explains who signs which form.
When to Book the Rater
Contact a rater once the permit is issued rather than at the end of the job. Timing depends on the item being verified:
- Before walls are closed: QII is inspected while the insulation is still visible, so on new homes, ADUs and additions the rater must visit before drywall.
- After equipment is installed: duct leakage, refrigerant charge, airflow and fan efficacy are tested on the working system.
- Before final inspection: the registered verification forms need to exist before the inspector signs off.
If a test fails, the contractor corrects the issue and the rater re-tests, so leave some room in the schedule.
What It Costs at the Registry Level
There are two separate costs. The rater's own fee for the site visit and testing is set by the rater, so ask for a quote. On top of that, the registry charges a per-project fee. CHEERS lists its ECC-Rater fees, per product per project, at $45 for new construction and $30 for an alteration, as listed in November 2026; fees can change, so check the CHEERS pricing page. The fee does not change with the number of measures tested.
Homeowners can access the CF1R in CHEERS with no project access fee; access to the CF2R installation documents carries a one-time $50 project access fee per project, not per document. Registering the CF1R is included in our report price where the project requires registration. The full breakdown is on our CHEERS registration fees page.
The Consumer Information Form and Owner Reports
In CHEERS, a Consumer Information Form must be completed before ECC field verification starts. After testing, a Project Owner Report is provided, and a Project Status Report is available once an independent ECC-Rater has verified and tested the work. Questions about a specific project can go to CHEERS at (800) 424-3377, and the CHEERS homeowner guide explains how owner access works.
HERS or ECC: Same Job, New Name
Under the 2025 Title 24 Standards, the California Energy Commission calls field verification ECC (Energy Code Compliance) verification and the testers ECC-Raters. Many contractors and building departments still say HERS, and the process works the same way. CHEERS is currently the only ECC-Provider the CEC lists as approved; another company has applied and is under review. For background on the registry change, see what the CalCERTS closure meant, and for what the rater's report itself contains, see what a HERS report is.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can my HVAC contractor do the HERS testing?
No. The rater must be independent of the installer. The contractor completes the CF2R for the installation, and a separate ECC (HERS) rater performs and records the verification.
Does a Title 24 report include HERS testing?
No. The Title 24 report is prepared from your plans before the permit and identifies what must be verified. Field testing happens later, on site. Our Title 24 vs HERS comparison sets out the differences.
What happens if the HERS test is skipped?
The building department checks the registered installation and verification forms at final inspection, so a project whose CF1R lists verified measures generally cannot pass final without them.
Who pays the CHEERS fee for the rater?
CHEERS charges its ECC-Rater fees to the rater's account, paid by credit card. Whether that fee is passed on separately is up to the rater, so ask whether their quote includes it.